When Universalism Met Nationalism

Justin Smith-Ruiu

In this final lecture of a course on the Enlightenment, Justin Smith-Ruiu examines the intellectual currents that both shaped and challenged Enlightenment thinking. He traces how figures like Leibniz, Rousseau, Voltaire, Herder, and Kant navigated tensions between cosmopolitanism and nationalism, civilization and culture, universalism and local identity. The lecture explores how Leibniz pitched philosophy to Peter the Great as the foundation for building a modern Russian navy, how debates over national languages became tools of identity construction, and how early racial theories attempted to naturalize human difference. Smith-Ruiu shows that the line between Enlightenment and counter-Enlightenment was never clean: soft nationalism shaded into hard nationalism, communitarianism challenged universalist ideals, and Romanticism's embrace of folk culture carried both liberating and dangerous possibilities. The lecture argues that understanding these tangled legacies remains essential, precisely because their unresolved tensions continue to animate political and intellectual life today.

Read Transcript › Watch on YouTube ›