The Counter-Enlightenment
Justin Smith-Ruiu
In this fifth lecture of his course on the Enlightenment and its discontents, Justin Smith-Ruiu pivots toward the thinkers that pushed back against Enlightenment ideals. He begins by mapping the intellectual landscape from Hume and Kant to modern anti-liberal thought, then retraces the utopian tradition from Plato and Campanella through Bacon's New Atlantis. The lecture examines how social contract theory, developed by Hobbes, Locke, and Rousseau, laid the groundwork for the modern nation-state, and how the construction of national identity became a political project in its own right. Smith-Ruiu then turns to the French Revolution as a turning point: the moment when Enlightenment universalism was tested by terror, colonial blowback, and the contradictions of imposed reason. He also considers the Dutch republican tradition and the fate of the public sphere in the age of the internet. The lecture closes by promising a deep dive into German Counter-Enlightenment thought, where the real challenge to Enlightenment philosophy takes shape.