Enlightenment and Its Discontents

Justin Smith-Ruiu centers this course on two questions: what was the Enlightenment, and why has it provoked lasting resistance? Covering nearly two centuries of intellectual history, from the scientific revolution around 1610 to the death of Kant in 1804, he identifies three pillars that define the movement: a challenge to authority and tradition, a commitment to universality, and a faith in progress. Leibniz serves as a main thread throughout the course.

The story begins with an older order of knowledge structured by authority. Smith-Ruiu recounts the legend of the clash between Galileo and a priest who refused to look through a telescope because Aristotle never mentioned the moons of Jupiter, then follows Descartes, Newton, and Leibniz as thought moved from a closed cosmos to an infinite universe. The rise of mechanical philosophy raised a harder problem. If nature runs like clockwork, what room is left for human freedom, divine intervention, or moral responsibility? Bacon, Boyle, Descartes, and Leibniz each tried to reconcile this picture of nature with Christian theology and the experience of free choice.

The course then turns to historical context. With the printing revolution, universities retreated as the central site of knowledge, replaced by the rise of scientific academies, salon culture, and royal patronage. Within these settings, Smith-Ruiu takes up empiricist and materialist approaches to what a human being is and what can be known of the external world. Smith-Ruiu resists tidy summaries, arguing that the Enlightenment cannot be reduced to materialism or empiricism alone.

Kant arrives as the culmination of Enlightenment thought. Hume had asked how we can claim to know that one thing causes another if all we observe is one event following another. Kant's Copernican revolution reframes the problem by asking what the mind itself contributes to experience, and Smith-Ruiu discusses Kant's third critique and its surprising convergence of aesthetics and biology.

The final lectures turn to the thinkers who disputed Enlightenment claims. Social contract theory, developed by Hobbes, Locke, and Rousseau, laid the groundwork for the modern nation-state, and the French Revolution tested Enlightenment universalism with terror, colonial blowback, and the contradictions of imposed reason. Rousseau and Herder pressed the claims of history, culture, and particular ways of life. Smith-Ruiu shows that the line between Enlightenment and Counter-Enlightenment was never clean: soft nationalism shaded into hard nationalism, and universalism and local identity remained entangled. The tensions that emerged in this period continue to shape our political and intellectual world today.

Justin Smith-Ruiu

Justin Smith-Ruiu

Justin Smith-Ruiu is Professor of Philosophy at the Université Paris Cité. He is the author, most recently, of Polyglot Empire: Leibniz, Russia, and the Discovery of Natural Language (Princeton University Press, 2027), On Drugs: Psychedelics, Philosophy, and the Nature of Reality (W. W. Norton, 2025), and The Internet Is Not What You Think It Is (Princeton University Press, 2022). The Main-Belt Asteroid 13585 Justinsmith is named after him.