# Authority, Universality, and Progress Speaker: Justin Smith-Ruiu Course: Enlightenment and Its Discontents Watch: https://ergo.org/videos/justin-smith-ruiu-authority-universality-and-progress Transcript: https://ergo.org/videos/justin-smith-ruiu-authority-universality-and-progress/transcript/ YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=njNSWSk8F6U When quoting, name the speaker and link to the watch URL. In this introductory lecture, Justin Smith-Ruiu lays out the scope and ambitions of a course spanning nearly two centuries of intellectual history, from the dawn of the scientific revolution around 1610 to the death of Kant in 1804 and the rise of German Romanticism. Drawing on his background in both history and philosophy of science, Smith-Ruiu identifies three pillars that define the Enlightenment as a movement: its challenge to authority and tradition, its commitment to universality, and its faith in progress. He acknowledges that "Enlightenment" remains a nebulous notion, one that requires careful conceptual analysis grounded in historical context. Leibniz emerges as a recurring figure, a polymath whose work serves as a main thread throughout the course. The lecture concludes by previewing the course's arc toward Counter-Enlightenment critics, including Rousseau and Herder, who mounted powerful challenges to Enlightenment assumptions. ## Introduction and Background Hello, I'm Justin Smith-Ruiu. I am a professor of philosophy at the Université Paris Cité in Paris. I am myself American, but I've been teaching in France for a number of years. ## History and Philosophy of Science Though I'm a philosopher, I teach in a department of history and philosophy of science, which is ultimately an interdisciplinary field, and requires us to appreciate and to deploy the methods of both philosophers and of historians. And the kind of work I do, and have done for some years, is the result of this intersection of different methodologies. ## Conceptual Analysis Meets Historical Context I'm interested, like other philosophers, in conceptual analysis, and in working through rigorous arguments. At the same time, I'm particularly interested in all the aspects of history that can help us to understand why a given figure in history promoted the ideas and deployed the arguments that we find them promoting. ## Leibniz: The Conducting Thread I have worked for many years on the philosophy of Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz, who is a German philosopher of the late 17th, early 18th centuries, a great rationalist philosopher in the tradition of Descartes and Spinoza, and also, finally, a real polymath and a graphomaniac. And he's often the conducting thread that binds together the different figures I touch on in courses I teach, and that's probably no exception here. ## From Scientific Revolution to German Romanticism Though I've tried to give you in this course the biggest picture I can, spanning mostly from around 1610, the beginning of the scientific revolution, to around the beginning of the 19th century, 1804, with the death of Kant and the beginnings of the period of German Romanticism. Our concern, then, is to trace out the long arc of a cluster of ideas that we put under the heading of Enlightenment, and to see how these ideas were critiqued and opposed under the heading of what will retroactively be called Counter-Enlightenment. ## Enlightenment and Counter-Enlightenment ## Defining the Enlightenment: A Nebulous Notion And so as I argue in the first of my lectures, the Enlightenment is a nebulous notion, difficult to pin down, but if you wish, you can draw out three very important headings that make ideas occurring within this period recognizably Enlightenment ideas. ## First Pillar: Authority and Tradition One is a changing attitude towards the weight of authority in making the case for a given philosophical position. Authority and tradition are subjected to a great transformation in this period. ## Second Pillar: Universality Another is the question of universality in both theoretical philosophy and natural philosophy, and in political theory, what we find is a kind of discovery of universality as an ideal across all these domains. ## Third Pillar: Progress And finally, progress. The question of the newfound possibility of moving from an inferior to a superior state or condition as an individual, as a rational thinker, but also as a society as a whole, and perhaps even nature itself could be subject to progress. So these three headings then help us to understand what is a very, very difficult to define, very nebulous notion. ## Course Structure and Counter-Enlightenment Critics And we move from there through an investigation of different authors, and different sub-problems within the broader scope of Enlightenment philosophy. And ultimately, in the end, we turn to some criticisms from figures who are typically designated as Counter-Enlightenment, such as Rousseau and Herder. So that's the course, and I hope you will enjoy it.